When you’re choosing a new asphalt roof, it’s easy to assume all shingles are basically the same. They may look similar from the ground, and nearly every manufacturer offers comparable colors and styles. So, does the brand printed on the package really make a difference?
Yes—but the brand name alone isn’t what makes a quality roof.
The manufacturer, specific shingle line, warranty, roofing system, and quality of the installation all work together to determine how well your new roof performs.
At Barringer Brothers Roofing, we install CertainTeed asphalt shingles for homeowners throughout the Metro East. Here’s why shingle brand matters and what homeowners should actually consider when comparing their options.
1. Shingle Quality Can Vary Between Manufacturers
Asphalt shingles aren’t all manufactured exactly the same.
Differences in construction, materials, design, and quality standards can affect how shingles handle wind, rain, temperature changes, and years of exposure to the elements.
This is one reason choosing a reputable manufacturer matters. Your roof is expected to protect your home for decades, so the shingles installed today need to continue performing years from now.
2. Not Every Shingle From the Same Brand Is Equal
Brand is only part of the decision.
Most major manufacturers offer several different shingle lines at different price and performance levels. A basic shingle and a higher-quality architectural shingle from the same manufacturer aren’t necessarily going to offer identical features.
When comparing estimates, don’t simply ask which brand a contractor uses. Ask which specific shingle they’re installing.
That gives you a much more accurate comparison.
3. Wind Resistance Matters in Southern Illinois
Illinois weather can put an asphalt roof through a lot.
Strong winds and severe thunderstorms are common throughout the Metro East, making proper shingle selection especially important.
Different shingles may carry different wind ratings and installation requirements. Choosing shingles designed for strong performance—and having them installed according to manufacturer specifications—can help your roof stand up to severe weather.
4. Manufacturer Warranties Aren’t All the Same
Warranty coverage is another reason shingle brand matters.
Different manufacturers and shingle products can offer different levels of coverage. It’s important to understand what the warranty covers, how long different portions of the coverage last, and whether there are installation requirements that must be followed.
A good roofing contractor should be able to explain the warranty rather than simply telling you that your shingles have one.
5. Color and Style Options Can Be Different
Performance is important, but your roof also makes up a large portion of your home’s exterior.
Shingle manufacturers offer different color blends, textures, and architectural styles. The right option can complement your siding, brick, gutters, and other exterior features while giving your home an updated appearance.
CertainTeed offers a wide selection of architectural shingle colors, giving homeowners plenty of options when choosing a roof that works with the rest of their home.
6. A Great Shingle Still Needs a Great Installation
This might be the most important part.
You can purchase quality shingles from a reputable manufacturer and still end up with roofing problems if they’re installed incorrectly.
Your roof is an entire system. Underlayment, flashing, ventilation, starter shingles, ridge caps, nail placement, and other installation details all affect its performance.
That’s why comparing roofing estimates based solely on the shingle brand doesn’t tell you the whole story.
Quality materials and quality installation need to go together.
Why Barringer Brothers Roofing Uses CertainTeed
At Barringer Brothers Roofing, we choose roofing products based on the quality and performance we want to provide our customers.
We install CertainTeed asphalt shingles because they offer dependable roofing products, a variety of architectural styles and colors, and warranty options that allow us to provide homeowners with a complete roofing system we trust.
Just as importantly, our experienced team installs each roof with attention to the details that help those materials perform the way they’re designed to.
So, Does Shingle Brand Really Matter?
Yes—but homeowners shouldn’t choose a new roof based on a logo alone.
When comparing roofing options, consider the:
- Manufacturer
- Specific shingle line
- Product features
- Wind rating
- Warranty
- Roofing system components
- Contractor installing the roof
The best roof isn’t simply the one with the most recognizable shingle brand. It’s a quality roofing system installed correctly by a contractor you trust.
Frequently Asked Questions
Barringer Brothers Roofing installs CertainTeed asphalt shingles for residential roofing projects.
CertainTeed is an established roofing manufacturer offering a variety of asphalt shingle products, including architectural shingles in numerous colors and styles. The right product depends on your home, budget, and roofing needs.
Architectural shingles generally offer a dimensional appearance and may provide different performance features than traditional three-tab shingles. Your roofing contractor can help you compare specific products rather than choosing based on appearance alone.
Absolutely. Even quality shingles can develop problems when they’re installed incorrectly. Proper installation of the complete roofing system is essential for long-term performance.
Yes, but make sure you’re comparing the specific shingle products and overall roofing systems—not simply manufacturer names. Installation quality, warranties, materials, and contractor experience should also factor into your decision.
Choose Quality Materials and Quality Installation
Choosing shingles is an important part of getting a new roof, but you don’t have to figure it out alone. Barringer Brothers Roofing can help you understand your options and choose a CertainTeed asphalt shingle that fits your home while providing the quality installation your roofing system needs.
Call Barringer Brothers Roofing at (618) 703-3036 or fill out our online contact form to schedule your free estimate.
